Application Question
Medium difficulty • Concept in a practical situation
Question 1
Applied ConceptA scientist wants to clone a human insulin gene into E. coli. She cuts both the human DNA and the plasmid vector with EcoRI. Explain why it is necessary to use the same restriction enzyme for both the source DNA and the vector, and what would happen if different enzymes were used.
- EcoRI recognises the palindromic sequence 5'-GAATTC-3' and cuts both strands, leaving identical 4-nucleotide 5'-AATT-3' sticky ends on all fragments; using the same enzyme on both human DNA and the plasmid ensures that the insulin gene fragment and the linearised vector have complementary sticky ends that can base-pair with each other.
- If different restriction enzymes were used (e.g., EcoRI for the insert and BamHI for the vector), the sticky ends generated would be non-complementary—the single-stranded overhangs would not be able to form hydrogen bonds with each other, preventing ligation by DNA ligase.
- The consequence would be failure to form a recombinant plasmid; even if blunt-end ligation were attempted, it would be far less efficient and would not be sequence-specific, potentially allowing the vector to re-ligate to itself without the insulin gene insert, reducing recombinant clone frequency.