Case Study
Passage with linked questions
Case Set 1
Case AnalysisPassage
Dr. Meena is a biochemist studying the chemical composition of a freshly isolated sample of human liver tissue. She grinds 5 grams of the tissue in trichloroacetic acid using a mortar and pestle, obtaining a thick slurry. After straining through cheesecloth, she collects two fractions. Fraction A (the filtrate) is a clear liquid, while Fraction B (the retentate) is a viscous residue. She analyses both fractions and finds that Fraction A contains amino acids, glucose, nucleotides, and inorganic ions, whereas Fraction B contains proteins, DNA, RNA, glycogen, and lipid-containing vesicles. She wonders why the lipid vesicles ended up in Fraction B despite lipids being small molecules. This experiment forms the basis of how scientists categorise the chemical constituents of living cells into micromolecules and macromolecules.
Question 1: What are Fraction A and Fraction B technically called, and what molecular weight range characterises the compounds in Fraction A?
- Fraction A is called the filtrate or the acid-soluble pool, while Fraction B is called the retentate or the acid-insoluble fraction.
- The compounds in Fraction A have molecular weights ranging from 18 to approximately 800 daltons, placing them in the category of micromolecules or simply biomolecules.
- Examples of compounds in Fraction A include amino acids, monosaccharides, nucleotides, fatty acids, and inorganic ions such as sodium, potassium, and phosphate.
Question 2: Why are lipids found in Fraction B (the acid-insoluble fraction) even though individual lipid molecules have molecular weights below 800 Da?
- Lipids are small molecular weight compounds (below 800 Da) and would normally pass into the filtrate; however, in the intact cell they are organised into membrane structures such as the cell membrane and organelle membranes.
- When the liver tissue is ground during analysis, these membranes are disrupted and break into small vesicles that are not water-soluble and therefore cannot pass through the cheesecloth during filtration.
- These membrane-derived lipid vesicles sediment with the acid-insoluble fraction along with true macromolecules; the chapter explicitly states that lipids are not strictly macromolecules but appear in the macromolecular fraction due to their membrane-associated organisation.
Question 3: Dr. Meena then burns a dried portion of the liver sample completely and collects the ash. What does the ash represent, and what does the experiment as a whole tell us about the difference between living tissue and earth's crust at the elemental level?
- The ash remaining after complete combustion of dried tissue represents the inorganic elements — such as calcium, magnesium, sodium, and potassium — and inorganic compounds like sulphate and phosphate that are present in living tissue; all carbon compounds are oxidised to gaseous CO2 and water vapour during burning.
- The experiment as a whole (acid fractionation + combustion) reveals the complete chemical composition of living tissue: organic compounds in both fractions plus inorganic constituents in the ash.
- When compared to earth's crust, living tissue contains the same elements but in dramatically different relative proportions: carbon is 18.5% of the human body versus only 0.03% of the earth's crust; hydrogen is 9.5% in the body versus 0.14% in the crust; this difference in relative abundance — not the presence of unique elements — is what distinguishes living matter from non-living matter.